This was supposed to be the intro to a discussion about my bike trip to Worms and Speyer (two cities with very interesting Jewish histories) last weekend. As usual, I rambled on a bit too much, so I'll turn my discussion of that trip into another post.
I've mentioned the fact that I'm Jewish to most of the people I've met in Germany, and here's the thing: it's made me much more uncomfortable than I thought it would. Germans are, as I've said, very conscious of the Holocaust, to the point where the mere mention of Judaism will cause most Germans to snap to attention. It's easy to see the dozens of questions swirling around in their head, but they don't ask any, and even if you start talking about the religion, there are never any follow-up questions.
(Example: during one of my first weekends in Germany, I was watching a soccer game in my apartment with about 15 of my flatmates' friends. At one point, one of the guys started talking about the US/Israel relationship with me, and when I prefaced my comment with "I'm Jewish, so…" the entire room fell silent. I spoke uninterrupted for about 30 seconds, and when I stopped, everyone sat pensively for a minute then started talking about soccer again. That was the end of the Israel talk.)
What makes this so frustrating is the fact that most of these people, by their own admission, have never met a Jew before. Now, I've popped plenty of Jew cherries before, but in every one of those situations the other person has been curious, probing and just a tad uninformed. Take my CS host in Strasbourg, for instance: Outside of Paris, Strasbourg has one of the largest Jewish populations in France. But despite seeing Jews walking around all the time, my host had never actually had a conversation with a Jew before. When I told him I wanted to check out the synagogue in town, he started rattling off questions—and not just silly, "do you celebrate Christmas?" type stuff, but insightful things about God, dating and everything in between. He even used my presence as an opportunity to strike up a conversation with a black-hatter on the street—something he had clearly wanted to do for a long time. Now, that being said, this guy wasn't extremely high on Judaism in general: he's a self-proclaimed atheist, and he saw (and probably still sees) Orthodox Jews as ultra-religious crackpots. But the point is that he asked. He engaged. Ignorance is a virtual non-issue as long as it's tempered with a healthy sense of curiosity.
But in Germany, you simply don't get that kind of engagement. Of course, this is not something unique to Judaism. In the month and a half that I've been in Germany so far, not once have I had a conversation about religion with a German (I've had several with other Americans). So it could very well be that I've come up against a simple cultural difference—Germans don't talk religion. But what makes it so much more painful is the fact that Germans are curious. They want to ask questions. But the ingrained mores of a self-conscious society seem to be getting in the way. Perhaps I'll find a way to get them to open up, but for now I'm stuck feeling mildly uncomfortable as people quietly stare at me when I say I'm Jewish.
One other note: Merkel's reaction to the Cologne court banning circumcision is quintessentially German. Forget the misguided claims of anti-circumcision activists. Forget the infringements on individual liberty. Hell, forget the Muslims. We just don't want to look bad for mistreating the Jews again. Sorry for the cynicism, but this does seem to be the state of German dialogue on Judaism (and race/religion in general) at this point. The general population seems to be pretty misinformed, and while the exceedingly politically correct atmosphere does keep minority groups' rights intact (the question is not if, but when this ruling gets overturned), it also stifles the possibility for constructive dialogue and allows ignorance to fester under a calm surface.